FIFA 11 vs. PES 2011: which one to choose?
71
Rather than give you two separate tests of new raw PES and FIFA, it was said that this year we would rather give you a comparison, based on a number of specific points, allowing you to make your informed choice event!
Gameplay
Konami seems he has learned the lesson since its PES 2011 game play offers finally temperate, posed, leaving truly reflected the differences between players. The pace of play has also been slow to our delight, the ball physics have been reviewed, and we now really feel like a real simulation hands. Developers are increasingly insisting that the player is forced to opt for manual passes, it will soften, but once mastered allow a depth of game much more enjoyable. And then we must admit that Konami had a brilliant idea by proposing a technical act of sticking to each direction the analog stick. Yet all is not perfect yet, and about management of contacts between players such as FIFA leads the dance by far. More generally, PES still sins in the management of its phases of attack still perfectible, see uncertain (because subject to teammates who toil for example, do not be put off, to make correct calls, etc ...) and guards often Strawberry. But the software of EA Sports, who had already one step ahead of previous years, does not really deserve to shine on the pan of the gameplay this year. He has thus had to solidify a little more solid bases Ultra before it, by moving a little more on the side of the simulation, particularly in terms of achieving the pass, much less obvious control, or even in duels, even more paramount. Even at the level of strikes and the feeling that they provide, EA Sports seems to be closer to the result reached by Konami, currently still unrivaled. In order to offer us an experience we can more effectively.
Realization
Next PES, this year was entitled to a pleasant surprise, with players faces often modeled with an accuracy bluffing, and with more realistic animation. Thus, they are able to make gestures to the natural gaits, the antithesis of the robotic movements which they bestow upon us in the previous phases. Too bad it all is penalized by an incomprehensible aliasing. Side of FIFA 11 now, we note a real improvement on the side of modeling players headlights, thanks to the proprietary technology ofEA Sports, the Personality + (which affects both the physical and technical players, c 'Note). But it is still too little to be able to take the pill at Konami on this issue. The fact that some players of FIFA 11 showing more hair cuts having nothing to do with their actual models is somewhat more work.
Game Modes / Online
PES 2011 plays the classic card overall on this, and we do not even include the Quick Match or Master League, which for years have gone furniture. We focus instead on how famous a Legend (to create a player and to mount one by one the steps to glory) somewhat improved, enriched phase "in the locker room," but unfortunately handicapped by an RN often inconsistent (see soft ...), which gives frankly want to swing the lever down and back in a game "classic". Everything is caught by a Master League Online squarely involved, since challenging you to a team of 11 goats, let's not mince words, a team of top-flight. To do this, you will have time to buy your players via an auction system shapely, because it was designed to maintain a balance between the teams. Unfortunate that the parties have difficulty in maintaining smooth and stable, because otherwise it's all good! Side FIFA 11 now, he plays the game the map of completeness, with a career that you can play on the field from the bench, or from 2 positions at once. Also, the Be A Pro mode is always so well put together, and it is a treat to see her foal, through an editor creates ultra full, improved over the games. Being able to take the place of the watchman is also a good point, brought this year, and should find its followers in line (because the face of AI, you'll still get bored very quickly ...) Side finally online the opportunity to indulge this year's 11 against 11 (a first in the genre) will appeal necessarily. And in all cases, the lovers of the game modes classic find no evil enough to do this online with FIFA 11.
Ambiance
PES provides us with his raw footage from 2011 of each stock glaring truth, and worn by players terribly well modelled. Visually, it's so on top, and it remains well above FIFA. By cons, once one begins to touch the sound environment is once again the game of EA Sports , which took the lead by far. Would that thanks to the ambiance of fire heard at meetings headlights. The fact that it is now possible to customize almost all the sounds in games played. it sticks quite a handicap in the field. Playing with fictional players, or how exactly filling the atmosphere in less than two.
Worth Reading
- PES 2011 vs. FIFA 11 | Reviews, Tips and Upcoming News
Excellent Review and Comparison between PES 2011 vs. FIFA 11
Conclusion
One would think that FIFA 11 would win without trouble, facing a PES always looking for the recipe. It was a mistake all along the line, and if the game ofEA Sports is still ahead for us this year, it would probably ensure his back for next year, as the soft Konami has this time managed to s provide an excellent foundation. More technical, though there a few gaps in terms of gameplay that prevent it from competing on equal terms with FIFA 11 that we play without a partition without fault happens again tu peaks of the genre!
|
|
Pro Evolution Soccer 2012 PES 12 PS3 Video Game Brand New Sealed US Version
Current Bid: $27.99
|
|
|
NEW PS2 PES 2012 Pro Evolution Soccer Sony PlayStation 2 GAME FREE SHIPPING
Current Bid: $23.20
|
|
|
Pro Evolution Soccer 2012 PS3 PES 12 Official Video Game Brand New Sealed
Current Bid: $27.99
|
|
|
FIFA Soccer 11 Sony Playstation 3 Brand New Factory Sealed Free Shipping!
Current Bid: $20.00
|
|
|
Playstation 3 PS3 FIFA Soccer 11 Brand New Factory Sealed Rated E For Everyone
Current Bid: $7.50
|
|
|
Playstation 3 PS3 FIFA Soccer 11 Brand New Factory Sealed Rated E For Everyone
Current Bid: $7.50
|
Video (FIFA 11 vs. PES 2011)
My Hubs
- Resident Evil 5 Review
An old mansion, tons of zombies, bloodthirsty mutants and abstruse puzzles. All this was 1996, the backdrop for one of the scariest and most successful to date video games of the 32-bit era and... - 17 months ago
- Medal Of Honor Game Review
Since the overwhelming success of the two Call of Duty - Modern WarfareTitles have been trying some free-riders on the throne of the venerable shooter series to cut. Only the former great rival Medal... - 17 months ago
- Review of FINAL FANTASY XIII
In FINAL FANTASY XIII goes to the player on a breathtaking journey through the floating world Cocoon and the cruel underworld Pulse meets and go to a variety of supposed allies. Through the seamless... - 18 months ago
- Vanquish Review
It is amazing: Since produce highly creative Japanese anime movies to write heart-wrenching stories in role-play - and get creative for a shooter like Vanquish only way to revive the US-Russia... - 18 months ago
- Battlefield: Bad Company 2 Review
What is the future of FPS? From canardage limitless in open environments, the arena in baston, murder in scripted sets closed? The action game in the first person to integrate tomorrow there are... - 18 months ago
- Wii Party Review
A few weeks before Christmas, Nintendo released with great fanfare its new party game, simply titled Wii Party. Or how Nintendo has every intention of relegating the classic games in the closet,... - 18 months ago
- Final Fantasy XIV Review
Final Fantasy XI MMO is a pretty high-threshold when compared with the more recent games in this genre. You will not, as we are accustomed today, sent from quest to quest and get no help in the form... - 18 months ago
- Review for Fallout: New Vegas
Universal truths are found in the strangest places. For example, are answered during basic training in the army, where questions of meaning and nonsense of battle helmet can be happy with sentences... - 18 months ago
CommentsLoading...
I think it all depends on where you set the priorities:
Those who place great emphasis on presentation and licenses will be happier with Fifa.
Who puts more emphasis on depth and gameplay, got PES. Has always been so and will probably always remain so.
Whoa I hear this argument can not manslaughter ...
If you PES disciples a not something else?
I myself was for many years and have a passion for PES to PES 2008 played extensively.
But even as a PES fan should slowly open your eyes and recognize the things caught up in FIFA gameplay is extremely and now is at an altitude!
The slightly better ball physics PES may still have, even if FIFA there caught up with this year's version again. The balloon of FIFA 09 / 10 is past.
But in terms of gameplay is much better at FIFA are:
- The defensive AI of the opponent. PES 11 now have played extensively in the demo, thanks to the long season you can also make a very good picture.
Fact is, even at the highest levels of difficulty, I may be partly in the opposing penalty area and the ball slide effortlessly combine.
- The goalkeeper AI, PES is also far turn back. PES resulted in 9.8 Every shot from the side to a rebound in 50% and thus at a Abstaubertor, it is mittlerweiel better, but in 1vs1 against the striker and wide shots at the goalie looks still very often really really stupid.
- The playful freedom.
Both dribbling, select the option even if I would like to shoot with the instep or precise with the inside.
The new "hard" edge at FIFA ...
There are many points in terms of gameplay in FIFA is now the better!
When I attacked the door with PES, I feel very restricted in terms of gameplay because I simply have far fewer choices my players to control.
- Are another feature in the FIFA gameplay is clearly the front, the 360 control and 360 tackles.
The player control is much smoother and in no way a "wannabe 360" system like you would with PES still be found there. It's just obvious that in 90% of cases of controlled players still drives the old 8-directions.
And a huge argument why FIFA in terms of gameplay is now at eye level:
Ability to select between using / Semi and full manual control.
If you want to take a serious picture of the FIFA gameplay then can we please play time 2-3 hours with manual control.
If you then still claimed the attacks, gates would be equal and the game would be unrealistic ... Sorry can not tell me seriously that he has looked closely at both games.
And unfortunately the problem with most FIFA / PES testing. The editors even paid with their fanboy glasses «go to the games.
I've seen in almost any test of FIFA last 2-3 years references to the gameplay issues I have listed above.
This is the game play can also manually seems most do not attract attention.
Since the game is plugged into the console, gezockt 2-3 games and you have made appear to be a picture.
Just ridiculous and this is called "professional" reporting?
The FIFA has the larger license pack is a fact. This point can not deny it.
What game now in terms of presentation and gameplay front, in my opinion, is now a matter of taste.
But this killer argument "FIFA has a bad gameplay and PES will be ahead in this increasingly" evidence just like this one has not played both games extensively.
Konami has done it this time at least
Well, unfortunately, is PES for me since FIFA 2010 death. If I want to have ps2 graphics and arcade football I can unpack and fifa 2002. Just ridiculous with the top players I can play the entire opposing team would (any difficulty) So rest fifa 2011
The best test is made Gamereactor as so often ... still make good tests.
Fifa
Graphics: 8
Playability: 9
Sound: 9
Addiction factor: 10
Total 9 / 10
PES
Graphics: 9
Playability: 9
Sound: 8
Addiction Factor: 9
Total 9 / 10
I find this a good rating, especially those are probably the only two who see more clearly and better assessment of PES in the image because even then (especially the player faces!)
If only Konami can just sort out the licensing issues PES would be perfect and better than Fifa every time. But for now this issue continues to linger because most people can't be bothered to go through the hassle of downloading the proper names.
I 'll go with FIFA!












Windy 18 months ago
So I have to say the two demos that I feel and the atmosphere at PES 2011 like it much better than 11th in Fifa And also like the feel of me the first times better in a long time. Since my Fifa is a bit old 08, I think the first time in years about it, to give preference to PES Fifa.